Aerial view of New York City with tall skyscrapers under a bright blue sky.

Running a business is a difficult job. You have to take care of your customers, your team, and your building or office. That’s why it’s important to have commercial property insurance. This type of insurance helps protects your business if something bad happens, like a fire, flood, storm, or theft.

But when disaster strikes, filing an insurance claim isn’t always easy. Sometimes, insurance companies don’t want to pay what they should. It’s important to understand how commercial property insurance claims work in New York.

In this blog post, you’ll know what to expect and how to protect your business.

What Is Commercial Property Insurance?

Commercial property insurance helps pay to fix or replace things your business owns. This can
include:

  • The building where your business is located
  • Furniture and equipment
  • Computers, phones, and tools
  • Signs, fences, and landscaping
  • Inventory (products you sell)

If a fire, storm, burst pipe, or other disaster causes damage, your insurance should help cover the costs. You can learn more about this from the New York State Department of Financial Services.

Understanding Coverage: What’s Included and What’s Not

Each insurance policy includes different kinds of coverage. Some may cover fire and storm damage, while others also cover theft or water damage. It’s important to read your policy carefully. Sometimes, businesses learn too late that something isn’t covered.

If you're not sure about your coverage, talk to a lawyer or insurance expert before a disaster occurs.

When Should You File a Claim?

You should file a claim when your business has property damage or loss that is covered by your policy. Some examples:

  • A fire burns part of your office or shop
  • A pipe breaks and water floods your building
  • A storm breaks windows or damages the roof
  • Someone breaks in and steals equipment or goods

As soon as something bad happens, take action right away. Many insurance policies have deadlines for filing claims.

A damaged room with broken furniture, peeling walls, and debris scattered across the floor.

Steps to Take After Damage Happens

If your business gets damaged, here’s what you should do:

  1. Stay Safe: Make sure everyone is safe. Call 911 if there’s a fire or serious damage.
  2. Take Pictures: Take photos and videos of everything that was damaged.
  3. Stop More Damage: Use tarps or boards to cover broken windows or holes in the roof.
  4. Call Your Insurance Company: Start the claims process right away.
  5. Save Receipts: Keep proof of what you spend to fix or protect your property.
  6. Get Help If You Need It: A lawyer or public adjuster can help with big or tricky claims.

You can find more tips from Ready.gov’s Business Emergency Planning Guide.

What Happens During the Claim Process?

Once you file your claim, the insurance company will:

  • Ask you to fill out forms
  • Send someone (an adjuster) to look at the damage
  • Review your policy for coverage
  • Offer a payment for the damage

This can take weeks or even months. Sometimes, they say damage isn’t covered or offer too little money. You can read more about how this process works in New York from NYC Business.

Types of Insurance Disputes You Might Face

There are different types of insurance disputes that New York business owners may face, such as:

  • Disagreements over coverage
  • Lowball payment offers
  • Delayed payments
  • Denied claims without reason
  • Miscommunication in party claims involving tenants or contractors

If you experience any of these, don’t give up. These are common and legal help is available.

Man sitting at a wooden table with his head resting on his arms, appearing sad or tired in a bright room.

Common Problems Business Owners Face

We’ve helped many clients across New York with commercial insurance claim problems. These are some common issues:

  • The insurance company says damage isn’t covered
  • They offer way less than the damage is worth
  • They delay payment for weeks
  • They blame you for the damage

Insurance companies often try to protect their profits, not your business.

How a Lawyer Can Help with a Lawsuit

Sometimes, the only way to get the money you’re owed is to file a lawsuit. You should have someone by your side too.

A good insurance claim attorney who knows New York insurance claim laws can:

  • Look at your policy to see what’s covered
  • Handle the insurance company for you
  • Fight to get you full payment
  • File a lawsuit if the company breaks the rules

At Vargas Gonzalez Delombard, LLP, we help business owners like you deal with unfair treatment from insurance companies.

Why Timing Matters

New York has rules about how long you have to file a claim or a lawsuit. If you miss these deadlines, you could lose your chance.

  • File your commercial insurance claim right away
  • Save all letters, emails, and notes
  • Don’t sign anything without reading it or getting help

For more info on insurance law in New York, visit the New York State Bar Association.

Final Tips for Business Owners

Here’s how to be ready in case of future damage:

  • Keep your insurance policy somewhere safe
  • Take pictures of your building and stuff before damage happens
  • Know who to call if something bad happens
  • Make a plan for what your team should do in an emergency

And always trust your gut. If something doesn’t feel right with your claim, get help.

Partners of Vargas Gonzalez Delombard LLP, Rene Delombard (left), Louis Gonzalez (middle), and Andrew Vargas (right) - standing outdoors with a cityscape in the background, dressed in business suits and smiling

Need Help with a Claim?

At Vargas Gonzalez Delombard LLP, we help New York business owners stand up to insurance companies. We’ll explain your rights, review your policy, and fight for what you deserve. Contact us today, we provide free consultations.



Back to Blog

Free Claims Consultation Tell Us About Your Case

Get a Free Case Evaluation
Contact us media
Accessibility: If you are vision-impaired or have some other impairment covered by the Americans with Disabilities Act or a similar law, and you wish to discuss potential accommodations related to using this website, please contact our Accessibility Manager at (407) 794-3056.
Contact Us